PGR2021-00098 - Vmware Inc v. Cirba IP Inc et al.

Details
PATENT NUMBER
10951459 High-Tech
APPL. NUMBER
16687966
PETITIONER
Vmware Inc
Large Operating Company
PATENT OWNER
Cirba IP Inc
Cirba Inc
Cibra IP Inc
Operating Company
STATUS
Final Written Decision Appealed
FILING DATE
2021-07-06
INSTITUTION DATE
2021-12-10
TERMINATION DATE
2022-12-07
PET. COUNSEL
Morrison & Foerster LLP
P.O. COUNSEL
Reichman Jorgensen LLP
Reichman Jorgensen Lehman & Feldberg LLP
AUTHOR JUDGE
Timeline
Petition
Notice of Filing Date
Preliminary Response
Institution Decision
Final Decision
Jul
Aug
Sep
Oct
Nov
Dec
2022
Feb
Mar
Apr
May
Jun
Jul
Aug
Sep
Oct
Nov
Dec
2023
Feb
Mar
Apr
May
Jun
Jul
Aug
Sep
Oct
Nov
Dec
2024
Feb
Mar
Apr
May
Jun
Jul
Aug
Sep
Oct
Docket
Paper No.
Date
Party
Type
Name
12021-07-06PetitionerPower of AttorneyPetitioner's Power of Attorney
22021-07-06PetitionerPetitionPetition for Postgrant Review of U.S. Patent No. 10,951,459
10012021-07-06PetitionerExhibit 1001
10022021-07-06PetitionerExhibit 1002
10032021-07-06PetitionerExhibit 1003
10042021-07-06PetitionerExhibit 1004
10052021-07-06PetitionerExhibit 1005
10062021-07-06PetitionerExhibit 1006
10072021-07-06PetitionerExhibit 1007
10082021-07-06PetitionerExhibit 1008
10092021-07-06PetitionerExhibit 1009
10102021-07-06PetitionerExhibit 1010
10112021-07-06PetitionerExhibit 1011
10122021-07-06PetitionerExhibit 1012
10132021-07-06PetitionerExhibit 1013
10142021-07-06PetitionerExhibit 1014
10152021-07-06PetitionerExhibit 1015
10162021-07-06PetitionerExhibit 1016
10172021-07-06PetitionerExhibit 1017
10182021-07-06PetitionerExhibit 1018
10192021-07-06PetitionerExhibit 1019
10202021-07-06PetitionerExhibit 1020
32021-07-19BoardNotice of Filing DateNotice of Accord Filing Date
42021-07-27Potential Patent OwnerMandatory NoticePatent Owner's Mandatory Notices
52021-07-27Potential Patent OwnerPower of AttorneyPatent Owner's Power of Attorney
62021-08-25PetitionerOtherPetitioner's Motion for Pro Hac Vice Admission of Andrea L. Scripa
72021-08-25PetitionerOtherPetitioner's Motion for Pro Hac Vice Admission of Stephen Liu
82021-08-25PetitionerOtherPetitioner's Updated Mandatory Notices
92021-08-25PetitionerPetitioner's Exhibit List
10212021-08-25PetitionerExhibit 1021
10222021-08-25PetitionerExhibit 1022
102021-09-07BoardOtherOrder: ORDER Granting Petitioners Motions for Admission Pro Hac Vice of Andrea L. Scripa and Stephen Liu 37 C.F.R. 42.10
112021-09-14Potential Patent OwnerPreliminary ResponsePatent Owner's Election to Waive Its Preliminary Response
122021-12-10BoardInstitution DecisionInstitution Decision: Granting Institution of Post-Grant Review 35 U.S.C. sec. 324
132021-12-10BoardOtherOrder: Scheduling Order
142022-03-04Potential Patent OwnerResponsePatent Owner's Response
152022-03-04Potential Patent OwnerPatent Owner's Exhibit List
20012022-03-04Potential Patent OwnerDeclaration of Dr. Vijay Madisetti in Support of Patent Owner's Response
20022022-03-04Potential Patent OwnerList of Materials Considered by Dr. Vijay Madisetti
20032022-03-04Potential Patent OwnerCurriculum Vitae of Dr. Vijay Madisetti
20042022-03-04Potential Patent OwnerOrder, D.I. 1161, Cirba Inc. (d/b/a Densify) and Cirba IP, Inc., v. VMware, Inc., Case 1:19-cv-0742-LPS (D. Del.), Feb. 24, 2022
20052022-03-04Potential Patent OwnerMemorandum Opinion, D.I. 1160, Cirba Inc. (d/b/a Densify) and Cirba IP, Inc., v. VMware, Inc., Case 1:19-cv-0742-LPS (D. Del.), Feb. 24, 2022
20062022-03-04Potential Patent OwnerJoint Claim Construction Brief, D.I. 1094, Cirba Inc. (d/b/a Densify) and Cirba IP, Inc., v. VMware, Inc., Case 1:19-cv-0742-LPS (D. Del.), Feb. 24, 2022
20072022-03-04Potential Patent OwnerDICTIONARY BY MERRIAM-WEBSTER (available at https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/place)
20082022-03-04Potential Patent OwnerTHE MERRIAM-WEBSTER DICTIONARY (2004)
20092022-03-04Potential Patent OwnerROGET���S II THE NEW THESAURUS (3d ed. 2003)
20102022-03-04Potential Patent OwnerNewman, Morris et al., IBM, SERVER CONSOLIDATION WITHVMWARE ESX SERVER (January 2005)
20112022-03-04Potential Patent OwnerBrodkin, Jon, Virtual Server Sprawl Highlights Security Concerns, April 30, 2008
20122022-03-04Potential Patent OwnerProvazza, Alyssa, FAQ: Devising a Server Consolidation Plan, November 24, 2010
20132022-03-04Potential Patent OwnerVMware, Inc., Virtualization
20142022-03-04Potential Patent OwnerThe Computer Language Company Inc., Virtual Environment
20152022-03-04Potential Patent OwnerHammersley, Eric, PROFESSIONAL VMWARE SERVER 1-9 (2007)
20162022-03-04Potential Patent OwnerVMware, Inc., Introduction to VMware Infrastructure, Update 2 and later for ESX Server 3.5, ESX Server 3i version 3.5, VirtualCenter 2.5, copyright 2008, 2009, pp. 1-20
20172022-03-04Potential Patent OwnerDefense Industry Daily, The Virtual Armed Forces: US Military Turns to Virtualization, August 15, 2011
20182022-03-04Potential Patent OwnerSteele, Colin, Face-Off: VMware vs. Microsoft in the Hypervisor Wars, May 1, 2009
20192022-03-04Potential Patent OwnerKerner, Sean Michael, KVM vs. Xen vs. VMware. Is it a Hypervisor War?, September 6, 2008
20202022-03-04Potential Patent OwnerVenezia, Paul, Ramming Microsoft Down IT���s Throat, September 21, 2009
20212022-03-04Potential Patent OwnerDubie, Denise, VMware, MS Battle Over Virtualization Management, June 27, 2008
20222022-03-04Potential Patent OwnerRosenblum, Mendel & Garfinkel, Tal, Virtual Machine Monitors: Current Technology and Future Trends, COMPUTER, Vol. 38, No. 5, 39-47 (May 2005)
162022-03-11PetitionerOtherPetitioner's Objections to Evidence Submitted with Patent Owner's Response
172022-03-25Potential Patent OwnerOtherPatent Owner's Supplemental Evidence Responding to Petitioner's Objections
182022-04-29PetitionerMandatory NoticePetitioner's Updated Mandatory Notices
192022-05-09Potential Patent OwnerOtherJoint Notice of Stipulation to Move Due Dates 2 and 3
202022-05-24Potential Patent OwnerMandatory NoticePatent Owner's Updated Mandatory Notices
212022-06-09PetitionerOtherNotice of Deposition of Dr. Vijay Madisetti PH.D.
222022-06-24PetitionerReplyPetitioner's Reply to Patent Owner's Response
10232022-06-24PetitionerExhibit 1023
10242022-06-24PetitionerExhibit 1024
232022-07-22Potential Patent OwnerSur-ReplyPatent Owner's Sur-Reply
242022-07-26Potential Patent OwnerOtherPatent Owner's Request for Oral Hearing
252022-07-29PetitionerOtherPetitioner's Request for Oral Argument
262022-08-11Potential Patent OwnerPatent Owner's Updated Exhibit List
272022-08-11Potential Patent OwnerOtherPATENT OWNERS MOTION FOR PRO HAC VICE ADMISSION OF WESLEY WHITE UNDER 37 C.F.R. § 42.10(c)
20232022-08-11Potential Patent OwnerDeclaration of Wesley White In Support of Motion for Pro Hac Vice
282022-08-16BoardOtherGranting Patent Owners Motion for Pro Hac Vice Admission of Wesley White 37 C.F.R. § 42.10
292022-08-17Potential Patent OwnerMandatory NoticePatent Owner's Updated Mandatory Notices
302022-08-17Potential Patent OwnerPower of AttorneyPatent Owner's Updated Power of Attorney
312022-08-24BoardConduct of ProceedingOrder: Panel Change Order
322022-08-25BoardOtherORDER Setting Oral Argument 37 C.F.R. 42.70
332022-09-09BoardOtherLEAP Practitioner Request and Verification Form (Petitioner)
342022-09-12BoardOtherRevised Hearing Order
352022-09-12Potential Patent OwnerOtherPatent Owner's Demonstrative Exhibit
362022-09-12PetitionerExhibitPetitioner's Demonstrative Exhibit
372022-11-22BoardOtherOther: Hearing transcript
382022-12-07BoardFinal DecisionFinal Written Decision: original
392023-01-31Potential Patent OwnerNotice of AppealPatent Owner's Notice of Appeal
2023-02-01PetitionerOtherPetitioner's Motion for Withdrawal and Substitution of Counsel
402023-02-01PetitionerOtherPetitioner's Motion for Withdrawal and Substitution of Counsel
412023-02-01PetitionerMandatory NoticePetitioner's Updated Mandatory Notices
422023-03-06BoardOtherORDER Granting Petitioner’s Motion to Withdraw and Substitute Counsel 37 C.F.R. § 42.10
432024-08-14BoardOtherOther: Fed Circuit mandate
Grounds Asserted

Not a member? Sign up for free!