IPR2022-01586 - Porsche Cars North America Inc et al. v. Yechezkal Evan Spero

Details
PATENT NUMBER
11208029 Other
APPL. NUMBER
17152399
PETITIONER
Porsche Cars North America Inc
Volkswagen Group Of America Inc
Large Operating Company
PATENT OWNER
Yechezkal Evan Spero
NPE (Individual)
STATUS
Final Written Decision Appealed
FILING DATE
2022-10-03
INSTITUTION DATE
2024-01-16
TERMINATION DATE
2024-05-22
PET. COUNSEL
Sterne, Kessler, Goldstein & Fox PLLC
Haug Partners LLP
P.O. COUNSEL
Brooks Kushman PC
AUTHOR JUDGE
Timeline
Petition
Notice of Filing Date
Preliminary Response
Institution Decision
Institution Decision
Final Decision
Oct
Nov
Dec
2023
Feb
Mar
Apr
May
Jun
Jul
Aug
Sep
Oct
Nov
Dec
2024
Feb
Mar
Apr
May
Jun
Jul
Aug
Sep
Oct
Nov
Dec
2025
Feb
Mar
Docket
Paper No.
Date
Party
Type
Name
12022-10-03PetitionerPetitionIPR2022-01586 Petition for Inter Partes Review
22022-10-03PetitionerPower of AttorneyIPR2022-01586 Petitioner's Power of Attorney
10012022-10-03PetitionerEX1001 - 029 Patent
10022022-10-03PetitionerEX1002 - 029 Patent Prosecution History
10032022-10-03PetitionerEX1003 - Jiao Declaration
10042022-10-03PetitionerEX1004 - Jiao CV
10052022-10-03PetitionerEX1005 - Beam US6144158
10062022-10-03PetitionerEX1006 - Thominet US20010019486A1
10082022-10-03PetitionerEX1008 - Kobayashi US6049749
10092022-10-03PetitionerEX1009 - Braun WO2002004247A1
10102022-10-03PetitionerEX1010 - Karlsson WO1998054030A1
10112022-10-03PetitionerEX1011 - Harbers WO2001001038A1
10122022-10-03PetitionerEX1012 - Gotou US5588733
10152022-10-03PetitionerEX1015 - Westermann 2002
10162022-10-03PetitionerEX1016 - Adaptive Front Lighting Systems (AFS)
10172022-10-03PetitionerEX1017 - Hogrefe
10182022-10-03PetitionerEX1018 - Loewenau
10192022-10-03PetitionerEX1019 - Manassero 1998
10202022-10-03PetitionerEX1020 - Hamm
10222022-10-03PetitionerEX1022 - Muller US5975734
10232022-10-03PetitionerEX1023 - Manassero 1999
10242022-10-03PetitionerEX1024 - Westermann 1999
10252022-10-03PetitionerEX1025 - Diem
10262022-10-03PetitionerEX1026 - Kobayashi
10272022-10-03PetitionerEX1027 - Vukotich
10282022-10-03PetitionerEX1028 - Worner
10292022-10-03PetitionerEX1029 - van den Berg
10302022-10-03PetitionerEX1030 - NHTSA Survey
10312022-10-03PetitionerEX1031 - Watanabe
10322022-10-03PetitionerEX1032 - Amended Complaint
10332022-10-03PetitionerEX1033 - 551 Reexam File History (Part 2 of 3)
10342022-10-03PetitionerEX1034 - Uchida US6127947
10352022-10-03PetitionerEX1035 - District Court Statistics
2022-11-29Patent OwnerNotice : Mandatory Notice
32022-11-29BoardNotice of Filing DateNotice: Notice filing date accorded
42023-02-27Patent OwnerMandatory NoticeNotice : Mandatory Notice
52023-02-27Patent OwnerPower of AttorneyNotice : Power of Attorney
62023-02-28Patent OwnerPreliminary ResponsePreliminary Response to IPR2022-01586
20012023-02-28Patent OwnerEx 2001 Turk Declaration
20022023-02-28Patent OwnerEx 2002 Turk CV
20032023-02-28Patent OwnerEx 2003 Unified Pettion
20042023-02-28Patent OwnerEx 2004 Harbers US64060172
20052023-02-28Patent OwnerEx 2005 Comparison of Harbers to Harbers 172
72023-05-24BoardInstitution DecisionInstitution Decision: Grant
82023-05-24BoardOtherSCHEDULING ORDER
92023-06-07Patent OwnerMandatory NoticeUpdated Mandatory Notice - 0110IPR - 11,208,029
102023-06-08PetitionerOtherPetitioner's Objections to Evidence
112023-06-09Patent OwnerMandatory NoticeUpdated Mandatory Notice - 0110IPR - 11208029
122023-07-24Patent OwnerOtherNotice of Deposition of Jianzhong Jiao 2022-01586
132023-08-16Patent OwnerResponsePatent Owner's Response to Petition
20062023-08-16Patent OwnerSupplemental Turk Declaration
20072023-08-16Patent OwnerJiao Deposition Transcript
20082023-08-16Patent OwnerIPR2023-00318 Petition
20092023-08-16Patent OwnerIPR2023-00318 Jiao Declaration
20102023-08-16Patent OwnerSPIE Etendue concerns for automotive headlamps using white LEDs Jiao 2003
20112023-08-16Patent OwnerBass Handbook of Optics 3rd Edition Volume II 2010
20122023-08-16Patent OwnerSAE Studies for Headlamp Optical Design Using LEDs Jiao 2004
20132023-08-16Patent OwnerSAE Optical Transform Limitations in Headlamp Photometric Performance Jiao 2005
20142023-08-16Patent OwnerLEDs Magazine Major contributors in LED and lighting standards have led the SSL revolution Jiao 2018
20152023-08-16Patent OwnerSPIE High-efficiency reflector optics Volume 6670 Jiao 2007
20162023-08-16Patent OwnerNavigant Energy Saving Estimates of Light Emitting Diodes in Niche Lighting Applications 2008
20172023-08-16Patent OwnerWIPO Patent Publication WO005147A1 Flaaten
142023-08-23PetitionerOtherPetitioner's Objections to Evidence
152023-08-28PetitionerMandatory NoticePetitioner's Updated Mandatory Notices
162023-10-04PetitionerOtherNotice of Deposition
172023-11-08PetitionerReplyPetitioner's Reply
10362023-11-08PetitionerEX1036 - Jiao Declaration
10372023-11-08PetitionerEX1037 - Turk Deposition Transcript
10382023-11-08PetitionerEX1038 - Leighty
10392023-11-08PetitionerEX1039 - Lowrie
10402023-11-08PetitionerEX1040 - Kobayashi
10412023-11-08PetitionerEX1041 - The International System of Units
10422023-11-08PetitionerEX1042 - Surface Vehicle Recommended Practice
10432023-11-08PetitionerEX1043 - Turk Diagram
10442023-11-08PetitionerEX1044 - 49 CFR 571.108
10452023-11-08PetitionerEX1045 - SAEJ387.1987
182023-11-16Patent OwnerOtherIPR2022-01586 Patent Owner Objection to Evidence
192023-11-27Patent OwnerOtherNotice of Deposition of Jianzhong Jiao 2022-01586
202023-12-20Patent OwnerSur-ReplyPatent Owners Sur Reply to Petitioners Reply to Patent Owner Response 2022-01586
20182023-12-20Patent OwnerEx. 2018 Condensed Jiao Deposition Transcript
212023-12-28PetitionerOtherPetitioner's Objections to Evidence
222024-01-03Patent OwnerMandatory NoticeUpdated Mandatory Notice - IPR2022-01586 - 11208029
232024-01-10PetitionerOtherRequest for Oral Argument
242024-01-10Patent OwnerOtherPatent Owner Request for Oral Argument IPR2022-01586
252024-01-16BoardInstitution DecisionInstitution decision and grant of joinder, IPR2023-01122
262024-01-23BoardOtherORDER Setting Oral Argument 37 C.F.R. § 42.70
272024-01-31PetitionerOtherPetitioner Volkswagen Group of America, Inc.'s Motion to Exclude
282024-02-07Patent OwnerOtherPatent Owners Opposition to Motion to Exclude IPR2022-01586
20272024-02-07Patent OwnerEx. 2027 2023-06-23 Letter to Fitzsimmons re objections to evidence
20282024-02-07Patent OwnerEx. 2028 2023-09-07 Letter to Fitzsimmons re objections to evidence
292024-02-14PetitionerReplyPetitioner's Reply to Patent Owner's Opposition to Petitioner's Motion to Exclude Evidence
10472024-02-14PetitionerEX1047 - E-mail
302024-02-20Patent OwnerExhibitCover for Demonstrative 2029 & updated exhibit list IPR2022-01586
312024-02-20PetitionerExhibitPetitioner's Updated Exhibit List
10482024-02-20PetitionerEX1048 - Petitioner's Demonstratives
20292024-02-20Patent OwnerEx. 2029 Demonstratives IPR2022-01586
322024-03-13BoardOtherOther: Hearing transcript
332024-05-22BoardFinal DecisionFinal Written Decision: original
342024-06-21Patent OwnerRequest for Director ReviewPatent Owners Request for Director Review 2022-01586
31002024-06-24BoardEx.3100
352024-07-31BoardDirector Review DispositionDirector Review denial on FWD
362024-10-02Patent OwnerNotice of AppealNotice of Appeal
Grounds Asserted

Not a member? Sign up for free!