IPR2019-01102 - Volkswagen Group Of America Inc v. Carucel Investments LP

IPR2019-01102 - Volkswagen Group Of America Inc v. Carucel Investments LPReport Error

Details

PATENT NUMBER

7848701 High-Tech

APPL. NUMBER

11733069

PETITIONER

Volkswagen Group Of America Inc
Large Operating Company

PATENT OWNER

Carucel Investments LP
NPE (Individual)

STATUS

Final Written Decision Appealed

FILING DATE

2019-05-20

INSTITUTION DATE

2019-11-14

TERMINATION DATE

2020-11-06

PET. COUNSEL

Sterne, Kessler, Goldstein & Fox PLLC

P.O. COUNSEL

Gavrilovich, Dodd & Lindsey, LLP
Warren Rhoades LLP
Law Offices of Elvin E. Smith, III PLLC

AUTHOR JUDGE

Paul J. Korniczky
Andrew Hirshfeld

PANEL JUDGE

Thomas L. Giannetti
Daniel J. Galligan
Paul J. Korniczky
Andrew Hirshfeld

Timeline

Petition

Notice of Filing Date

Preliminary Response

Institution Decision

Final Decision

Request for Rehearing

Rehearing Decision

May

Jun

Jul

Aug

Sep

Oct

Nov

Dec

2020

Feb

Mar

Apr

May

Jun

Jul

Aug

Sep

Oct

Nov

Dec

2021

Feb

Mar

Apr

May

Jun

Jul

Aug

Sep

Oct

Nov

Dec

2022

Feb

Mar

Apr

May

Jun

Jul

Aug

Sep

Oct

Nov

Dec

2023

Feb

Mar

Apr

May

Jun

Jul

Aug

Sep

Oct

Nov

Dec

2024

Feb

Mar

Apr

May

Jun

Docket

Show Exhibits

Paper No.	Date	Party	Type	Name


1	2019-05-20	Petitioner	Power of Attorney	Petitioner's Power of Attorney
2	2019-05-20	Petitioner	Petition	Petition for Inter Partes Review
1001	2019-05-20	Petitioner		Ex. 1001 - 701 Patent
1002	2019-05-20	Petitioner		Ex. 1002 - 701 File History
1003	2019-05-20	Petitioner		Ex. 1003 - Denning Declaration
1004	2019-05-20	Petitioner		Ex. 1004 - Scott Denning CV
1005	2019-05-20	Petitioner		Ex. 1005 - 5,276,686 (Ito)
1006	2019-05-20	Petitioner		Ex. 1006 - 5,504,786 (Gardner)
1007	2019-05-20	Petitioner		Ex. 1007 - 5,109,390 (Gilhousen390)
1008	2019-05-20	Petitioner		Ex. 1008 - 4,001,692 (Fenwick)
1009	2019-05-20	Petitioner		Ex. 1009 - 5,559,865 (Gilhousen865)
1010	2019-05-20	Petitioner		Ex. 1010 - Calhoun
1011	2019-05-20	Petitioner		Ex. 1011 - The Bell System Technical Journal (Young)
1012	2019-05-20	Petitioner		Ex. 1012 - The Bell System (Donald)
1013	2019-05-20	Petitioner		Ex. 1013 - Overview of the Global System (Scourias)
1014	2019-05-20	Petitioner		Ex. 1014 - VisiCom
1015	2019-05-20	Petitioner		Ex. 1015 - Law Enforcement News (News)
1016	2019-05-20	Petitioner		Ex. 1016 - Standard Communications (Standard)_Part 6
1017	2019-05-20	Petitioner		Ex. 1017 - Vercauteren
1018	2019-05-20	Petitioner		Ex. 1018 - System Application for Wireless Indoor Communications (Acampora)
1019	2019-05-20	Petitioner		Ex. 1019 - Dual-Polarized Channel Outages (Mottl)
1020	2019-05-20	Petitioner		Ex. 1020 - Effect of Fading Correlation (Salz)
1021	2019-05-20	Petitioner		Ex. 1021 - Honig
1022	2019-05-20	Petitioner		Ex. 1022 - Gavrilovich
1023	2019-05-20	Petitioner		Ex. 1023 - 904 File History
1024	2019-05-20	Petitioner		Ex. 1024 - Forssen
1025	2019-05-20	Petitioner		Ex. 1025 - Lomp
1026	2019-05-20	Petitioner		Ex. 1026 - Capone
1027	2019-05-20	Petitioner		Ex. 1027 - Hemmady
1028	2019-05-20	Petitioner		Ex. 1028 - Blakeney II
1029	2019-05-20	Petitioner		Ex. 1029 - Gilhousen501
1030	2019-05-20	Petitioner		Ex. 1030 - Mears
1031	2019-05-20	Petitioner		Ex. 1031 - Marque-Pucheu
1032	2019-05-20	Petitioner		Ex. 1032 - Paneth
1033	2019-05-20	Petitioner		Ex. 1033 - Webster
3	2019-05-29	Board	Notice of Filing Date	Notice of Accord Filing Date
4	2019-06-07	Potential Patent Owner	Mandatory Notice	Patent Owner Mandatory Notice
5	2019-08-22	Potential Patent Owner	Power of Attorney	Power of Attorney
6	2019-08-28	Potential Patent Owner	Preliminary Response	PO Preliminary Response
7	2019-11-14	Board	Institution Decision	Trial Instituted Document
8	2019-11-14	Board	Other	Scheduling Order
9	2019-12-20	Potential Patent Owner	Power of Attorney	PO Updated Power of Attorney
10	2019-12-20	Potential Patent Owner	Other	PO Updated Mandatory Notice
11	2019-12-20	Potential Patent Owner	Other	PO Notice of Deposition
12	2020-02-07	Potential Patent Owner	Response	Patent Owner Response
2100	2020-02-07	Potential Patent Owner		Exhibit 2100
2101	2020-02-07	Potential Patent Owner		Exhibit 2101
2102	2020-02-07	Potential Patent Owner		Exhibit 2102
2103	2020-02-07	Potential Patent Owner		Exhibit 2103
2104	2020-02-07	Potential Patent Owner		Exhibit 2104
2105	2020-02-07	Potential Patent Owner		Exhibit 2105
2106	2020-02-07	Potential Patent Owner		Exhibit 2106
2107	2020-02-07	Potential Patent Owner		Exhibit 2107
2108	2020-02-07	Potential Patent Owner		Exhibit 2108
2109	2020-02-07	Potential Patent Owner		Exhibit 2109
2110	2020-02-07	Potential Patent Owner		Exhibit 2110
2111	2020-02-07	Potential Patent Owner		Exhibit 2111
2112	2020-02-07	Potential Patent Owner		Exhibit 2112
13	2020-02-14	Petitioner	Other	Petitioner's Objections to Evidence
14	2020-03-06	Potential Patent Owner	Other	PO Updated Mandatory Notice
15	2020-03-12	Petitioner	Other	Petitioner's Notice of Deposition of Mark R. Lanning
16	2020-03-20	Petitioner	Other	Petitioners' Updated Notice Regarding Deposition of Mark R. Lanning
17	2020-04-07	Board	Other	REVISED SCHEDULING ORDER
18	2020-05-14	Petitioner	Other	Petitioner's Notice of Deposition of Mark R. Lanning
19	2020-06-26	Petitioner	Reply	Petitioner's Reply
1034	2020-06-26	Petitioner		EX1034 - Denning Reply Declaration
1035	2020-06-26	Petitioner		EX1035 - Lanning Declaration (Barkan Litigation)
1036	2020-06-26	Petitioner		EX1036 - Oxford Desk Dictionary Definitions
1037	2020-06-26	Petitioner		EX1037 - Cessna 152
1038	2020-06-26	Petitioner		EX1038 - ITU Document Cited By Lanning
1039	2020-06-26	Petitioner		EX1039 - Lanning Deposition Transcript - 2020-06-02
1040	2020-06-26	Petitioner		EX1040 - Lanning Deposition Transcript - 2020-06-03
1041	2020-06-26	Petitioner		EX1041 - Lanning Deposition Transcript - 2020-06-04
1042	2020-06-26	Petitioner		EX1042 - Lanning Deposition Transcript - 2020-06-05
1043	2020-06-26	Petitioner		EX1043 - USPN5621784 (Tiedemann784)
1044	2020-06-26	Petitioner		EX1044 - USPN6292651 (Dapper)
1045	2020-06-26	Petitioner		EX1045 - FAA Runway Safety Best Practices Brochure
1046	2020-06-26	Petitioner		EX1046 - USPN5289527 (Tiedemann527)
1047	2020-06-26	Petitioner		EX1047 - Pyndiah
1048	2020-06-26	Petitioner		EX1048 - Jakubowski
20	2020-07-22	Potential Patent Owner	Other	PATENT OWNER¿¿¿S REQUEST FOR ORAL ARGUMENT UNDER 37 C.F.R. ¿¿ 42.70(a)
21	2020-07-22	Petitioner	Other	Petitioner's Request for Oral Argument
22	2020-07-27	Potential Patent Owner	Sur-Reply	PATENT OWNER¿¿¿S SUR-REPLY TO PETITIONER¿¿¿S REPLY TO PATENT OWNER¿¿¿S RESPONSE
23	2020-08-10	Potential Patent Owner	Sur-Reply	PATENT OWNER¿¿¿S SUR-REPLY TO PETITIONER¿¿¿S REPLY TO PATENT OWNER¿¿¿S RESPONSE
24	2020-08-12	Board	Other	Oral Argument (37 C.F.R. 42.70)
25	2020-08-24	Petitioner		Petitioner's Updated Exhibit List
26	2020-08-24	Potential Patent Owner		PATENT OWNER¿¿¿S UPDATED EXHIBIT LIST
1049	2020-08-24	Petitioner		EX1049 - Petitioner's Demonstratives
2200	2020-08-24	Potential Patent Owner		Ex. 2200 - Patent Owner Oral Argument Demonstratives
27	2020-09-14	Board	Other	Hearing Transcript
28	2020-11-06	Board	Final Decision	Termination Decision Document
29	2020-12-06	Potential Patent Owner	Request for Rehearing	PATENT OWNER¿¿¿S REQUEST FOR REHEARING UNDER 37 C.F.R. ¿¿ 42.71(d)
30	2021-01-06	Board	Rehearing Decision	Decision Denying Request for Rehearing
31	2021-03-10	Potential Patent Owner	Notice of Appeal	PATENT OWNER��S NOTICE OF APPEAL
32	2021-10-13	Potential Patent Owner	Request for Director Review	PATENT OWNER��S REQUEST FOR DIRECTOR REVIEW
3100	2021-10-19	Board		Ex. 3100 Director Review Request
33	2021-12-06	Board	Director Review Disposition	Order Denying Request for Director Review
34	2021-12-20	Potential Patent Owner	Request for Director Review	PATENT OWNER��S REQUEST FOR LEAVE TO FILE A MOTION TO RECONSIDER DIRECTOR REVIEW AND NOTICE OF INADEQUATE REVIEW
36	2022-02-07	Potential Patent Owner	Notice of Appeal	PATENT OWNER��S AMENDMENT TO MARCH 10, 2021 NOTICE OF APPEAL
37	2024-04-09	Board	Other	Other: Fed Circuit mandate
38	2024-04-09	Board	Other	Other: other court decision

Grounds Asserted

Not a member? Sign up for free!