IPR2015-01674 - TCL Communication Technology Holdings Ltd et al. v. Telefonaktiebolaget LM Ericsson

IPR2015-01674 - TCL Communication Technology Holdings Ltd et al. v. Telefonaktiebolaget LM EricssonReport Error

Details

PATENT NUMBER

RE43931 High-Tech

APPL. NUMBER

11078916

PETITIONER

TCL Communication Technology Holdings Ltd
Tct Communication Technology Holdings Ltd
TCL Corp
Large Operating Company

PATENT OWNER

Telefonaktiebolaget LM Ericsson
Operating Company

STATUS

Final Written Decision

FILING DATE

2015-08-12

INSTITUTION DATE

2016-02-17

TERMINATION DATE

2017-02-13

PET. COUNSEL

Sheppard, Mullin, Richter & Hampton LLP
Morgan, Lewis & Bockius LLP

P.O. COUNSEL

Oblon, McClelland, Maier & Neustadt, LLP

AUTHOR JUDGE

Barbara A. Benoit

PANEL JUDGE

Benjamin D. M. Wood
Patrick R. Scanlon
Barbara A. Benoit
Stacy B. Margolies

Timeline

Petition

Notice of Filing Date

Preliminary Response

Institution Decision

Final Decision

Aug

Sep

Oct

Nov

Dec

2016

Feb

Mar

Apr

May

Jun

Jul

Aug

Sep

Oct

Nov

Dec

2017

Feb

Mar

Apr

May

Jun

Jul

Aug

Sep

Oct

Nov

Dec

2018

Docket

Show Exhibits

Paper No.	Date	Party	Type	Name


1	2015-08-12	Petitioner	Power of Attorney	Power of Attorney
2	2015-08-12	Petitioner	Petition	Petition for Inter Partes Review of U.S. Patent No. RE43,931
1001	2015-08-12	Petitioner		USRE43931
1002	2015-08-12	Petitioner		Complaint - filed January 8, 2015
1003	2015-08-12	Petitioner		RE43931 - One Touch Ultra 960 Infringement Cont
1004	2015-08-12	Petitioner		US6278888
1005	2015-08-12	Petitioner		US6131047
1006	2015-08-12	Petitioner		US6278888 File History
1007	2015-08-12	Petitioner		USRE43931 File History
1008	2015-08-12	Petitioner		US6424830
1009	2015-08-12	Petitioner		EP0499012A2
1010	2015-08-12	Petitioner		US5615384
1011	2015-08-12	Petitioner		US5889236
1012	2015-08-12	Petitioner		US4566001
1013	2015-08-12	Petitioner		US5621437
1014	2015-08-12	Petitioner		transducer - Dictionary_com
1015	2015-08-12	Petitioner		elongate - American Heritage Dict
1016	2015-08-12	Petitioner		Horowitz
1017	2015-08-12	Petitioner		US3382588
1018	2015-08-12	Petitioner		US3696409
1019	2015-08-12	Petitioner		US4972496
1020	2015-08-12	Petitioner		BYTE - Simon
1021	2015-08-12	Petitioner		Time - Simon
1022	2015-08-12	Petitioner		US4550221
1023	2015-08-12	Petitioner		US6037930
1024	2015-08-12	Petitioner		US5856822
1025	2015-08-12	Petitioner		US5543588
1026	2015-08-12	Petitioner		Buxton - A Study in Two Handed Input
1027	2015-08-12	Petitioner		US5825352
1028	2015-08-12	Petitioner		US5943052
1029	2015-08-12	Petitioner		US6009338
1030	2015-08-12	Petitioner		US5923861
1031	2015-08-12	Petitioner		US5663748
1032	2015-08-12	Petitioner		US5745116
1033	2015-08-12	Petitioner		US6363259
1034	2015-08-12	Petitioner		Newton MessagePad
1035	2015-08-12	Petitioner		Nokia Annual Report - 1996
1036	2015-08-12	Petitioner		US5748185
1037	2015-08-12	Petitioner		US5710844.pdf
1038	2015-08-12	Petitioner		FRAND Action Complaint
1039	2015-08-12	Petitioner		Ericsson's Motion for Leave to Amend Complaint
1040	2015-08-12	Petitioner		FRAND Action Second Amended Complaint
1041	2015-08-12	Petitioner		Complaint - Case 214-cv-00667 (E.D. Tex. 2015)
1042	2015-08-12	Petitioner		Court Order Denying Motion for Leave to Amend
1043	2015-08-12	Petitioner		US 5936615
1044	2015-08-12	Petitioner		Operating Sys Ref Manual for the Lisa (1983)
1045	2015-08-12	Petitioner		MS word disk 1983
1046	2015-08-12	Petitioner		web.stanford.edu_dept_SUL_library_mac_primary_docs_pr1
1047	2015-08-12	Petitioner		US6037930
1048	2015-08-12	Petitioner		US4220815
1049	2015-08-12	Petitioner		US4198539
1050	2015-08-12	Petitioner		US5451723
1051	2015-08-12	Petitioner		US4972496
1052	2015-08-12	Petitioner		EP0239705A1
1053	2015-08-12	Petitioner		Evolution of Touch-Bloomberg
1054	2015-08-12	Petitioner		HP 150 Touchscreen
1055	2015-08-12	Petitioner		Linus Write-Top Computer
1056	2015-08-12	Petitioner		IBM ThinkPad 360PE Review
1057	2015-08-12	Petitioner		Palm Pilot 1000 Technology
1058	2015-08-12	Petitioner		Gavilan SC Laptop
1059	2015-08-12	Petitioner		Apple PowerBook 500 Series UserGuide
1060	2015-08-12	Petitioner		Macintosh PowerBook 540 Tech Specs
1061	2015-08-12	Petitioner		IBM ThinkPad 360PE 2620 Touch Flip Screen
1062	2015-08-12	Petitioner		PDP 1 Manual 1961
1063	2015-08-12	Petitioner		computerhistory.org - XD116
1064	2015-08-12	Petitioner		vt100.net
1065	2015-08-12	Petitioner		DEC 1957 to Present 1978
1066	2015-08-12	Petitioner		Apple II - nmah_33
1067	2015-08-12	Petitioner		IBM PC - nmah_90
1068	2015-08-12	Petitioner		Timeline of Computer History
1069	2015-08-12	Petitioner		US5920310
1070	2015-08-12	Petitioner		History of Mouse
1071	2015-08-12	Petitioner		Microsoft Word History
1072	2015-08-12	Petitioner		Microsoft Windows History
1073	2015-08-12	Petitioner		US3482241
1074	2015-08-12	Petitioner		Lee - Touchscreen Paper
1075	2015-08-12	Petitioner		Sears - A new era for touchscreen applications
1076	2015-08-12	Petitioner		Plaisant - Touchscreen Interfaces paper
1077	2015-08-12	Petitioner		GUIFX
1078	2015-08-12	Petitioner		Bitzer - PLATO_IV_Dec68
1079	2015-08-12	Petitioner		EO Getting Started
1080	2015-08-12	Petitioner		Sep1993 MacWorld Cover
1081	2015-08-12	Petitioner		US5526422
1082	2015-08-12	Petitioner		EP0473465A1
1083	2015-08-12	Petitioner		US5276917
1084	2015-08-12	Petitioner		US5293639
1085	2015-08-12	Petitioner		US5179724
1086	2015-08-12	Petitioner		Razavi
1087	2015-08-12	Petitioner		US5892475
1088	2015-08-12	Petitioner		EP0721272A2
1089	2015-08-12	Petitioner		US8812059
1090	2015-08-12	Petitioner		US20140362018
1205	2015-08-12	Petitioner		Declaration of Andrew Wolfe
3	2015-08-21	Board	Notice of Filing Date	Notice of Filing Date Accorded to Petition
4	2015-09-02	Potential	Power of Attorney	Power of Attorney
5	2015-09-02	Potential	Other	Related Matters
6	2015-11-23	Potential Patent Owner	Preliminary Response	Patent Owner Preliminary Response
7	2016-02-17	Board	Institution Decision	Decision Institution of Inter Partes Review
8	2016-02-17	Board	Other	Scheduling Order
9	2016-03-02	Potential Patent Owner	Other	Patent Owner's Objection to Evidence
10	2016-03-16	Petitioner	Other	Petitioners Updated Mandatory Notice
11	2016-04-04	Potential Patent Owner	Other	Patent Owner's List of Proposed Motions
12	2016-04-06	Potential Patent Owner	Other	Patent Owner's Notice of Deposition of Dr. Andrew Wolfe
13	2016-04-11	Board	Other	Order - re Consolidation of Cases
14	2016-04-18	Potential Patent Owner	Other	Patent Owner's Submission of Transcript
15	2016-04-18	Potential Patent Owner	Other	Patent Owner's Exhibit List
2001	2016-04-18	Potential Patent Owner		Exibit 2001
16	2016-04-30	Petitioner	Power of Attorney	Power of Attorney
17	2016-04-30	Petitioner	Other	Updated Mandatory Notice
18	2016-05-23	Petitioner	Other	IPR2015-01674 Petitioners Mandatory Notice
19	2016-06-20	Potential Patent Owner	Response	Patent Owner Response
20	2016-06-20	Potential Patent Owner	Other	Patent Owner Updated Exhibit List
2002	2016-06-20	Potential Patent Owner		Exhibit 2002
2003	2016-06-20	Potential Patent Owner		Exhibit 2003
2004	2016-06-20	Potential Patent Owner		Exhibit 2004
2005	2016-06-20	Potential Patent Owner		Exhibit 2005
2006	2016-06-20	Potential Patent Owner		Exhibit 2006
2007	2016-06-20	Potential Patent Owner		Exhibit 2007
2008	2016-06-20	Potential Patent Owner		Exhibit 2008
2009	2016-06-20	Potential Patent Owner		Exhibit 2009
2010	2016-06-20	Potential Patent Owner		Exhibit 2010
2011	2016-06-20	Potential Patent Owner		Exhibit 2011
2012	2016-06-20	Potential Patent Owner		Exhibit 2012
2013	2016-06-20	Potential Patent Owner		Exhibit 2013
2014	2016-06-20	Potential Patent Owner		Exhibit 2014
2015	2016-06-20	Potential Patent Owner		Exhibit 2015
2016	2016-06-20	Potential Patent Owner		Exhibit 2016
2017	2016-06-20	Potential Patent Owner		Exhibit 2017
2018	2016-06-20	Potential Patent Owner		Exhibit 2018
2019	2016-06-20	Potential Patent Owner		Exhibit 2019
2020	2016-06-20	Potential Patent Owner		Exhibit 2020
2021	2016-06-20	Potential Patent Owner		Exhibit 2021
2022	2016-06-20	Potential Patent Owner		Exhibit 2022
2023	2016-06-20	Potential Patent Owner		Exhibit 2023
2024	2016-06-20	Potential Patent Owner		Exhibit 2024
2025	2016-06-20	Potential Patent Owner		Exhibit 2025
2026	2016-06-20	Potential Patent Owner		Exhibit 2026
2027	2016-06-20	Potential Patent Owner		Exhibit 2027
2028	2016-06-20	Potential Patent Owner		Exhibit 2028
2029	2016-06-20	Potential Patent Owner		Exhibit 2029
2030	2016-06-20	Potential Patent Owner		Exhibit 2030
2031	2016-06-20	Potential Patent Owner		Exhibit 2031
2032	2016-06-20	Potential Patent Owner		Exhibit 2032
2033	2016-06-20	Potential Patent Owner		Exhibit 2033
2034	2016-06-20	Potential Patent Owner		Exhibit 2034
2035	2016-06-20	Potential Patent Owner		Exhibit 2035
2036	2016-06-20	Potential Patent Owner		Exhibit 2036
2037	2016-06-20	Potential Patent Owner		Exhibit 2037
2038	2016-06-20	Potential Patent Owner		Exhibit 2038
2039	2016-06-20	Potential Patent Owner		Exhibit 2039
2040	2016-06-20	Potential Patent Owner		Exhibit 2040
2041	2016-06-20	Potential Patent Owner		Exhibit 2041
2042	2016-06-20	Potential Patent Owner		Exhibit 2042
2043	2016-06-20	Potential Patent Owner		Exhibit 2043
2044	2016-06-20	Potential Patent Owner		Exhibit 2044
2045	2016-06-20	Potential Patent Owner		Exhibit 2045
2046	2016-06-20	Potential Patent Owner		Exhibit 2046
2047	2016-06-20	Potential Patent Owner		Exhibit 2047
2048	2016-06-20	Potential Patent Owner		Exhibit 2048
2049	2016-06-20	Potential Patent Owner		Exhibit 2049
2050	2016-06-20	Potential Patent Owner		Exhibit 2050
2051	2016-06-20	Potential Patent Owner		Exhibit 2051
2052	2016-06-20	Potential Patent Owner		Exhibit 2052
2053	2016-06-20	Potential Patent Owner		Exhibit 2053
2054	2016-06-20	Potential Patent Owner		Exhibit 2054
2057	2016-06-20	Potential Patent Owner		Exhibit 2057
2060	2016-06-20	Potential Patent Owner		Exhibit 2060
2061	2016-06-20	Potential Patent Owner		Exhibit 2061
2062	2016-06-20	Potential Patent Owner		Exhibit 2062
2063	2016-06-20	Potential Patent Owner		Exhibit 2063
2064	2016-06-20	Potential Patent Owner		Exhibit 2064
2065	2016-06-20	Potential Patent Owner		Exhibit 2065
2066	2016-06-20	Potential Patent Owner		Exhibit 2066
2067	2016-06-20	Potential Patent Owner		Exhibit 2067
2068	2016-06-20	Potential Patent Owner		Exhibit 2068
2069	2016-06-20	Potential Patent Owner		Exhibit 2069
2070	2016-06-20	Potential Patent Owner		Exhibit 2070
2071	2016-06-20	Potential Patent Owner		Exhibit 2071
2072	2016-06-20	Potential Patent Owner		Exhibit 2072
2073	2016-06-20	Potential Patent Owner		Exhibit 2073
2074	2016-06-20	Potential Patent Owner		Exhibit 2074
2075	2016-06-20	Potential Patent Owner		Exhibit 2075
2076	2016-06-20	Potential Patent Owner		Exhibit 2076
21	2016-06-27	Petitioner	Other	Petitioners' Deposition Notice of Jean Renard Ward - IPR2015-01674
22	2016-06-27	Petitioner	Other	Petitioners Objections to Evidence - IPR2015-01674
23	2016-07-19	Petitioner	Other	Petitioners Objections to Supplemental Evidence - IPR2015-01674
24	2016-09-20	Petitioner	Reply	Petitioner Reply to Patent Owner Response ISO IPR
1209	2016-09-20	Petitioner		Ward 071416 Condensed
1210	2016-09-20	Petitioner		Ward 071516 Condensed
1211	2016-09-20	Petitioner		Suppl Declaration of Andrew Wolfe PhD
1212	2016-09-20	Petitioner		TCL1541 Datasheet
1213	2016-09-20	Petitioner		8XC552 Overview
1214	2016-09-20	Petitioner		MPLC004A Datasheet
1215	2016-09-20	Petitioner		80C552-83C552 Datasheet
1216	2016-09-20	Petitioner		Interface Circuits Data Book, Texas Instruments Inc. (1987)
25	2016-09-27	Potential Patent Owner	Other	Patent Owner's Objection to Evidence
26	2016-11-10	Petitioner	Other	Petitioners' Request for Oral Hearing
27	2016-11-10	Potential Patent Owner	Other	Patent Owner's Request for Oral Argument
28	2016-11-10	Petitioner	Other	Petitioners' Motion to Exclude Evidence
1217	2016-11-10	Petitioner		Petitioners' Objections to Evidence
1218	2016-11-10	Petitioner		Petitioners' Objections to Patent Owner's Supplemental Evidence
1219	2016-11-10	Petitioner		Declaration of Jean Renard Ward (Unfiled Exhibit 2077)
1220	2016-11-10	Petitioner		Declaration of Sameer Gokhale (Unfiled Exhibit 2078)
29	2016-11-25	Potential Patent Owner	Other	Patent Owner's Opposition to Petitioner's Motion to Exclude Evidence
30	2016-11-30	Petitioner	Other	Petitioners¿¿¿ Reply to Patent Owner¿¿¿s Opposition to Motion to Exclude
31	2016-12-06	Board	Other	Trial Hearing Order
32	2016-12-13	Petitioner	Other	Petitioners' Demonstrative Exhibits for Oral Argument
33	2016-12-13	Potential Patent Owner	Other	Patent Owner Demonstrative Exhibits for Oral Argument
34	2017-01-31	Board	Other	Record of Oral Hearing
35	2017-02-13	Board	Final Decision	Final Written Decision

Grounds Asserted

Not a member? Sign up for free!