IPR2013-00292 - Microsoft Corp v. Surfcast Inc

IPR2013-00292 - Microsoft Corp v. Surfcast IncReport Error

Details

PATENT NUMBER

6724403 High-Tech

APPL. NUMBER

09702325

PETITIONER

Microsoft Corp
Large Operating Company

PATENT OWNER

Surfcast Inc
NPE (Patent Assertion Entity)

STATUS

Final Written Decision Appealed

FILING DATE

2013-05-22

INSTITUTION DATE

2013-11-19

TERMINATION DATE

2014-10-14

PET. COUNSEL

Sidley Austin LLP

P.O. COUNSEL

DLA Piper LLP
VLP Law Group LLP

AUTHOR JUDGE

Matthew R. Clements

PANEL JUDGE

Michael P. Tierney
Matthew R. Clements
Joni Y. Chang

Timeline

Petition

Notice of Filing Date

Preliminary Response

Institution Decision

Request for Rehearing

Motion to Amend

Rehearing Decision

Opposition to Amendment

Reply to Opposition

Motion to Amend

Opposition to Amendment

Final Decision

Request for Rehearing

Rehearing Decision

May

Jun

Jul

Aug

Sep

Oct

Nov

Dec

2014

Feb

Mar

Apr

May

Jun

Jul

Aug

Sep

Oct

Nov

Dec

2015

Feb

Mar

Apr

May

Jun

Jul

Aug

Sep

Oct

Docket

Show Exhibits

Paper No.	Date	Party	Type	Name


1001	2013-05-20	Petitioner		US 6,724,403
1002	2013-05-20	Petitioner		6724403 File History
1004	2013-05-20	Petitioner		Expert CV
1005	2013-05-20	Petitioner		6,724,403 Prov. App.
1006	2013-05-20	Petitioner		Declaration
1007	2013-05-20	Petitioner		Part 1 - MSIE Resource Kit (Utah State)
1008	2013-05-20	Petitioner		MSIE Resource Kit (NCSU)
1009	2013-05-20	Petitioner		MSIE Resource Kit (LoC)
1010	2013-05-20	Petitioner		MSIE Resource Kit (Harvard)
1011	2013-05-20	Petitioner		US Patent 6832355
1012	2013-05-20	Petitioner		6832355 File History
1013	2013-05-20	Petitioner		US Patent 6118493
1014	2013-05-20	Petitioner		US Patent 6456334
1015	2013-05-20	Petitioner		US Patent 5432932
1016	2013-05-20	Petitioner		US Patent 5819284
1017	2013-05-20	Petitioner		US Patent 6807558
1018	2013-05-20	Petitioner		US Patent 5959621
1019	2013-05-20	Petitioner		US Patent 5479602
1020	2013-05-20	Petitioner		US Patent 5321750
1021	2013-05-20	Petitioner		US Patent 5712995
1022	2013-05-20	Petitioner		US Patent 5473745
1023	2013-05-20	Petitioner		US Patent 5140678
1024	2013-05-20	Petitioner		US Patent 6104700
1025	2013-05-20	Petitioner		US Patent 5721951
1026	2013-05-20	Petitioner		US Patent 5321808
1027	2013-05-20	Petitioner		US Patent 5550968
1028	2013-05-20	Petitioner		US Patent 4905171
1029	2013-05-20	Petitioner		US Patent 5901228
1030	2013-05-20	Petitioner		US Patent 6278448
1031	2013-05-20	Petitioner		US Patent 5848356
1032	2013-05-20	Petitioner		US Patent 6430405
1033	2013-05-20	Petitioner		US Patent 6047197
1034	2013-05-20	Petitioner		US Patent 6418309
1035	2013-05-20	Petitioner		US Patent 5635980
1036	2013-05-20	Petitioner		US Patent 6061576
1037	2013-05-20	Petitioner		US Patent 5371847
1038	2013-05-20	Petitioner		US Paternt 5764972
1039	2013-05-20	Petitioner		US Patent 636344
1040	2013-05-20	Petitioner		US Patent 5812123
1041	2013-05-20	Petitioner		US Patent 6411275
1042	2013-05-20	Petitioner		US Patent 4831556
1043	2013-05-20	Petitioner		US Patent 5757371
1044	2013-05-20	Petitioner		US Patent 5831664
1045	2013-05-20	Petitioner		US Patent 5838326
1046	2013-05-20	Petitioner		US Patent 5929854
1047	2013-05-20	Petitioner		US Patent 6160553
1048	2013-05-20	Petitioner		US Patent 6166738
1049	2013-05-20	Petitioner		US Patent 6188405
1050	2013-05-20	Petitioner		EP 0651544
1051	2013-05-20	Petitioner		WO1999026127
1052	2013-05-20	Petitioner		SurfCast Responses to Microsoft's First Set of Interrogatories
1053	2013-05-20	Petitioner		SurfCast Proposed Claim Constructions
1054	2013-05-20	Petitioner		SurfCast Rebuttal Proposed Claim Constructions
1055	2013-05-20	Petitioner		Microsoft Claim Construction Chart
1056	2013-05-20	Petitioner		First Amended Complaint
1057	2013-05-20	Petitioner		Amended Scheduling Order
1058	2013-05-20	Petitioner		Dictionary of Computer and Internet Terms
1059	2013-05-20	Petitioner		Microsoft Computer Dictionary
1060	2013-05-20	Petitioner		Part 1 - Nokia 9110 Users Guide 1998
1061	2013-05-20	Petitioner		Envoy Users Guide 1994
1062	2013-05-20	Petitioner		Simon User Manual 1994
1063	2013-05-20	Petitioner		Part 1 - Readings in Human-Computer Interaction
1064	2013-05-20	Petitioner		Part 1 - Designing the User Interface
1065	2013-05-20	Petitioner		Part 1 - Delivering Push
1066	2013-05-20	Petitioner		The User Interface for Sapphire
1067	2013-05-20	Petitioner		Taxonomy of Window Manager User Interfaces
1068	2013-05-20	Petitioner		A Tour Through Cedar
1069	2013-05-20	Petitioner		OpenStep User Interface Guidelines
1070	2013-05-20	Petitioner		User Interfaces for a Complex Robotic Task
1071	2013-05-20	Petitioner		Comparison of Tiled and Overlapping Windows
1072	2013-05-20	Petitioner		Inside Dynamic HTML
1073	2013-05-20	Petitioner		Constaint-Based Tile Windows
1074	2013-05-20	Petitioner		UWM - A User Interface for X Windows
1075	2013-05-20	Petitioner		The Complete Reference Front Page 2000
1076	2013-05-20	Petitioner		ABCs of Internet Explorer 4 Second Edition
1077	2013-05-20	Petitioner		The Complete Idiot's Guide to Windows 95 Second Edition
1078	2013-05-20	Petitioner		W3 - Handheld Devices Cell Phones Pagers Wireless pda
1079	2013-05-20	Petitioner		W3 HDML Note Submission HDML
1080	2013-05-20	Petitioner		W3 Note Submission HDML FAQ
1081	2013-05-20	Petitioner		UWPlanet - Handheld Device Transport Protocol
5	2013-05-22	Petitioner	Other	Exhibit List
6	2013-05-22	Petitioner	Petition	Petition for Inter Partes Review
7	2013-05-22	Petitioner	Power of Attorney	Power of Attorney
8	2013-05-22	Petitioner	Power of Attorney	Power of Attorney
1003	2013-05-22	Petitioner		Declaration of David R. Karger re US Patent 6724403
1082	2013-05-22	Petitioner		Microsoft's 2nd Supplemental Responses to SurfCast 1st Interrogatories
9	2013-05-24	Board	Notice of Filing Date	Notice of Filing Date Accorded to Petition
10	2013-05-24	Petitioner	Other	Request for Refund
11	2013-05-29	Petitioner	Other	Amendment to Section I.C.2
12	2013-06-17	Potential	Power of Attorney	Power of Attorney
13	2013-06-17	Potential	Power of Attorney	Power of Attorney
14	2013-06-17	Potential	Power of Attorney	Power of Attorney
15	2013-06-17	Potential	Power of Attorney	Power of Attorney
16	2013-06-17	Potential	Other	Related Matters
17	2013-08-26	Petitioner	Other	Agreement of Mandatory Discovery Pursuant to 37 CFR 42.51(A)
18	2013-08-26	Potential Patent Owner	Preliminary Response	Preliminary Response
2001	2013-08-26	Potential Patent Owner		Exhibit 2001
2002	2013-08-26	Potential Patent Owner		Exhibit 2002
19	2013-11-19	Board	Institution Decision	Decision - Institution of Inter Partes Review
20	2013-11-19	Board	Other	Scheduling Order
21	2013-12-10	Potential Patent Owner	Other	PO Proposed Motions
22	2013-12-10	Petitioner	Other	Petitioners List of Proposed Motions
23	2013-12-19	Petitioner	Request for Rehearing	Microsoft Request for Rehearing
24	2013-12-31	Potential Patent Owner	Other	Notice of Deposition
25	2013-12-31	Board	Other	Order - Conduct of the Proceeding
26	2014-01-03	Petitioner	Other	Transmittal Letter and Updated Exhibit List
1083	2014-01-03	Petitioner		Microsoft's Initial Disclosures
27	2014-01-24	Potential Patent Owner	Response	Patent Owner Response
28	2014-01-24	Potential Patent Owner	Motion to Amend	Motion for Conditional Amendment
2003	2014-01-24	Potential Patent Owner		Deposition of David Karger
2004	2014-01-24	Potential Patent Owner		Weadock Declaration in Support of Patent Owner Response
2005	2014-01-24	Potential Patent Owner		Declaration of Ovid Santoro
2006	2014-01-24	Potential Patent Owner		Declaration of Klaus Lagermann
2007	2014-01-24	Potential Patent Owner		Declaration of Tom Dachaene
2008	2014-01-24	Potential Patent Owner		Declaration of Richard Bone
2009	2014-01-24	Potential Patent Owner		Expunged
2051	2014-01-24	Potential Patent Owner		Diligence Calendar
2052	2014-01-24	Potential Patent Owner		Diligence Calendar 2
2053	2014-01-24	Potential Patent Owner		Weadock CV
2054	2014-01-24	Potential Patent Owner		IEEE Dictionary
2055	2014-01-24	Potential Patent Owner		MSIE Kit 1998
2056	2014-01-24	Potential Patent Owner		Graphics File Formats
2057	2014-01-24	Potential Patent Owner		Pentikousis: Comparative Study
2058	2014-01-24	Potential Patent Owner		Pentikousis: Comparative Study Abstract
2059	2014-01-24	Potential Patent Owner		SetPixel Function
2060	2014-01-24	Potential Patent Owner		Wessels: Web Caching
2061	2014-01-24	Potential Patent Owner		Yeager: Web Server Technology
2062	2014-01-24	Potential Patent Owner		Intel IPAD
2063	2014-01-24	Potential Patent Owner		Weadock Declaration in Support of Conditional Amendment
2064	2014-01-24	Potential Patent Owner		Merriam-Webster Dictionary
2065	2014-01-24	Potential Patent Owner		Claim Chart
2066	2014-01-24	Potential Patent Owner		US Provisional Application No. 60/162,522
2069	2014-01-24	Potential Patent Owner		Overview of Partitioning in MySQL
2070	2014-01-24	Potential Patent Owner		USNews: Lowest Acceptance Rates
2071	2014-01-24	Potential Patent Owner		NY & NJ: Toll Rate Table
29	2014-01-29	Board	Rehearing Decision	Decision - Request for Rehearing
30	2014-01-29	Petitioner	Other	Transmittal Letter and Updated Exhibit List
1084	2014-01-29	Petitioner		Deposition Transcript of David Karger (Signed)
31	2014-01-31	Potential Patent Owner	Other	Transmittal of PO Mandatory Notices
2072	2014-01-31	Potential Patent Owner		PO Mandatory Initial Disclosures
33	2014-02-10	Potential Patent Owner	Other	Motion To Seal
2010	2014-02-10	Potential Patent Owner		Expunged
2011	2014-02-10	Potential Patent Owner		Expunged
2012	2014-02-10	Potential Patent Owner		Expunged
2013	2014-02-10	Potential Patent Owner		E-mail
2014	2014-02-10	Potential Patent Owner		E-mail
2015	2014-02-10	Potential Patent Owner		Expunged
2016	2014-02-10	Potential Patent Owner		Expunged
2017	2014-02-10	Potential Patent Owner		Expunged
2018	2014-02-10	Potential Patent Owner		Expunged
2019	2014-02-10	Potential Patent Owner		E-mail
2020	2014-02-10	Potential Patent Owner		Expunged
2021	2014-02-10	Potential Patent Owner		Expunged
2022	2014-02-10	Potential Patent Owner		Expunged
2023	2014-02-10	Potential Patent Owner		Expunged
2024	2014-02-10	Potential Patent Owner		Expunged
2025	2014-02-10	Potential Patent Owner		Expunged
2026	2014-02-10	Potential Patent Owner		Expunged
2027	2014-02-10	Potential Patent Owner		Expunged
2028	2014-02-10	Potential Patent Owner		Expunged
2029	2014-02-10	Potential Patent Owner		Expunged
2030	2014-02-10	Potential Patent Owner		Expunged
2031	2014-02-10	Potential Patent Owner		E-mail
2032	2014-02-10	Potential Patent Owner		E-mail
2033	2014-02-10	Potential Patent Owner		Expunged
2034	2014-02-10	Potential Patent Owner		Expunged
2035	2014-02-10	Potential Patent Owner		Expunged
2036	2014-02-10	Potential Patent Owner		Expunged
2037	2014-02-10	Potential Patent Owner		Expunged
2038	2014-02-10	Potential Patent Owner		Expunged
2039	2014-02-10	Potential Patent Owner		Expunged
2040	2014-02-10	Potential Patent Owner		Expunged
2041	2014-02-10	Potential Patent Owner		Expunged
2042	2014-02-10	Potential Patent Owner		E-mail
2043	2014-02-10	Potential Patent Owner		Product Description
2044	2014-02-10	Potential Patent Owner		Product Description
2045	2014-02-10	Potential Patent Owner		Expunged
2046	2014-02-10	Potential Patent Owner		Expunged
2047	2014-02-10	Potential Patent Owner		Process Description
2048	2014-02-10	Potential Patent Owner		Data Structure
2049	2014-02-10	Potential Patent Owner		Expunged
2050	2014-02-10	Potential Patent Owner		Expunged
2067	2014-02-10	Potential Patent Owner		Expunged
2068	2014-02-10	Potential Patent Owner		Expunged
34	2014-02-11	Board	Other	Order - Conduct of the Proceedings
35	2014-02-14	Potential Patent Owner	Other	Motion To File Corrected Exhibits
36	2014-02-17	Petitioner	Other	Petitioner's Notice of Deposition of Klaus Lagermann
37	2014-02-17	Petitioner	Other	Petitioner's Notice of Deposition of Richard G. A. Bone
38	2014-02-17	Petitioner	Other	Petitioner's Notice of Deposition of Thomas Dechaene
39	2014-02-18	Petitioner	Other	Petitioner's Revised Notice of Deposition of Tom Dechaene
40	2014-02-18	Petitioner	Other	Petitioner's Notice of Deposition of Ovid Santoro
41	2014-02-19	Board	Other	Order - Conduct of the Proceeding
42	2014-02-20	Petitioner	Other	Petitioner Motion for Admission PHV of Scott Border wDecl
43	2014-02-25	Petitioner	Other	Notice of Deposition of Glenn Weadock
44	2014-03-04	Board	Other	Decision - Petitioner's Motion for Pro Hac Vice Admission of Scott M. Border
46	2014-03-31	Petitioner	Opposition to Amendment	Petitioner's Opposition to Patent Owner's Motion to Amend
47	2014-03-31	Petitioner	Other	Updated Exhibit List
1085	2014-03-31	Petitioner		Webster Definition of Access - Marked at Weadock Dep
1086	2014-03-31	Petitioner		Microsoft Definition of Access
1087	2014-03-31	Petitioner		Webster Definition of Periodic
1088	2014-03-31	Petitioner		Portions of Intranet Publishing for Dummies
1089	2014-03-31	Petitioner		Windows 98 Registry for Dummies
1090	2014-03-31	Petitioner		GDDM V3R2 Base Application Programming Guide
1091	2014-03-31	Petitioner		US5974567
1092	2014-03-31	Petitioner		Intranet Publishing for Dummies (full version of Ex. 1088)
1093	2014-03-31	Petitioner		US5577935
1094	2014-03-31	Petitioner		US7949687
1095	2014-03-31	Petitioner		US6616701
1096	2014-03-31	Petitioner		US7139970
1097	2014-03-31	Petitioner		html40
1098	2014-03-31	Petitioner		Inside Dynamic HTML
1099	2014-03-31	Petitioner		LaStrange_swm_An X Window Manager Shell
1100	2014-03-31	Petitioner		US5982445
1101	2014-03-31	Petitioner		American Heritage Dictionary - When
1102	2014-03-31	Petitioner		Bone Deposition Transcript
1104	2014-03-31	Petitioner		Lagermann Deposition Transcript
1106	2014-03-31	Petitioner		Weadock Deposition Transcript
1107	2014-03-31	Petitioner		EP1161716B1
1108	2014-03-31	Petitioner		US3760364
1109	2014-03-31	Petitioner		Lagermann - Maine Deposition (Redacted)
1110	2014-03-31	Petitioner		Reply Expert Declaration of David Karger
48	2014-04-03	Potential Patent Owner	Other	Transmittal of PO Deposition Transcripts
49	2014-04-03	Potential Patent Owner	Other	PO- Motion to Seal Deposition Transcripts
2073	2014-04-03	Potential Patent Owner		PO Deposition Transcript (Bone)
2074	2014-04-03	Potential Patent Owner		PO Deposition Transcript (Santoro)
2075	2014-04-03	Potential Patent Owner		PO Deposition Transcript (Lagermann)
2076	2014-04-03	Potential Patent Owner		PO Deposition Transcript (Dechaene)
2077	2014-04-03	Potential Patent Owner		PO Deposition Transcript (Weadock)
50	2014-04-10	Potential Patent Owner	Other	Notice of Deposition of Petitioner's Expert
51	2014-04-11	Board	Other	Order Conduct of the Proceeding
52	2014-04-21	Board	Other	ORDER Conduct of the Proceeding
53	2014-04-21	Board	Other	Revised Scheduling Order
54	2014-04-22	Petitioner	Reply	Corrected Petitioner's Reply to Patent Owner's Response
55	2014-04-22	Petitioner	Other	Transmittal Letter and Updated Exhibit List Accompnaying Corrected Reply Brief
1111	2014-04-22	Petitioner		Redline Petitioners Corrected Reply to Patent Owners Response
56	2014-04-23	Petitioner	Other	Transmittal Ltr and Updated Exhibit List
1112	2014-04-23	Petitioner		Transcript of 041614 Conference Call with PTAB
57	2014-04-24	Board	Other	Order - Conduct of the Proceeding - 37 CFR 42.5
58	2014-04-24	Board	Other	Decision - Motion to Seal - 37 CFR 42.14 and 42.54
59	2014-04-29	Board	Other	Decision - Motion to Seal
60	2014-05-02	Petitioner	Other	Petitioner's Notice of 2nd Deposition of Glenn Weadock
61	2014-05-06	Petitioner	Other	Transmittal Letter and Updated Exhibit List
1113	2014-05-06	Petitioner		20140424 Karger Deposition Transcript
62	2014-05-09	Potential Patent Owner	Reply to Opposition	Patent Owner Reply To Opposition to Amend
2078	2014-05-09	Potential Patent Owner		Ex 2078
2079	2014-05-09	Potential Patent Owner		Ex.2079
2080	2014-05-09	Potential Patent Owner		Ex.2080
2081	2014-05-09	Potential Patent Owner		Declaration of Glenn Weadock in support of Patent Owner Reply
2082	2014-05-09	Potential Patent Owner		Ex.2082
2083	2014-05-09	Potential Patent Owner		Ex. 2083
2084	2014-05-09	Potential Patent Owner		Ex.2084
2085	2014-05-09	Potential Patent Owner		Ex 2085
2086	2014-05-09	Potential Patent Owner		Ex. 2086
2087	2014-05-09	Potential Patent Owner		Ex.2087
2088	2014-05-09	Potential Patent Owner		Ex.2088-Redacted Belfiore Transcript
63	2014-05-12	Petitioner	Other	Petitioner's Amended Notice of Second Deposition of Glenn Weadock
64	2014-05-13	Potential Patent Owner	Other	Patent Owner Renewed Motion to Seal Confidential Exhibits
65	2014-05-22	Potential Patent Owner	Other	Patent Owner Transmittal of Expert Deposition Transcript and Updated Exhibit List
2089	2014-05-22	Potential Patent Owner		Transcript of second deposition of Patent Owner's expert, Glenn Weadock
66	2014-05-23	Petitioner	Other	Petitioner Request for Oral Argument
67	2014-05-23	Petitioner	Other	Petitioner Motion to Exclude
68	2014-05-23	Petitioner	Other	Petitioner Exhibit List
69	2014-05-23	Petitioner	Other	Petitioner Motion for Observation on Cross
70	2014-05-23	Potential Patent Owner	Other	Patent Owner Request for Oral Argument
71	2014-05-23	Potential Patent Owner	Other	Patent Owner - Motion for Observations on Deposition of Petitioner's Reply Witness
72	2014-05-23	Potential Patent Owner	Other	Patent Owner Motion to Exclude Petitioner Evidence
1114	2014-05-23	Petitioner		Microsoft Computer Dictionary for Program
2090	2014-05-23	Potential Patent Owner		Ex.2090 - Patent Owner service of objections to evidence on Petitioner
73	2014-05-28	Board	Other	Decision - Renewed Motion to Seal
74	2014-05-28	Board	Other	Order Trial Hearing
75	2014-05-30	Potential Patent Owner	Other	Patent Owner Transmittal of Corrected Motion to Amend
76	2014-05-30	Potential Patent Owner	Motion to Amend	Patent Owner Corrected Motion to Amend
2091	2014-05-30	Potential Patent Owner		Redline of Patent Owner Corrected Motion to Amend Relative to Original Motion
77	2014-06-04	Board	Other	Order - Conduct of Proceedings 37 C.F.R. 42.05
78	2014-06-05	Petitioner	Other	Transmittal and Updated Exhibit List
1115	2014-06-05	Petitioner		05-20-2014 Teleconference Transcript
79	2014-06-06	Petitioner	Other	Petitioner Opposition to Patent Owner Motion to Exclude
80	2014-06-06	Petitioner	Other	Petitioner Response to Patent Owner's Motion for Observation
81	2014-06-06	Potential Patent Owner	Other	Patent Owner Opposition to Petitioner Motion to Exclude Patent Owner Evidence
82	2014-06-06	Potential Patent Owner	Other	Patent Owner Response to Petitioner Observations
2092	2014-06-06	Potential Patent Owner		Expunged
83	2014-06-13	Petitioner	Other	Petitioner Reply ISO Its Motion to Exclude
84	2014-06-13	Petitioner	Opposition to Amendment	Petitioner Supp Opp to Patent Owner Corrected Motion to Amend
85	2014-06-13	Potential Patent Owner	Other	Patent Owner Reply to Petitioner's Opposition to Patent Owner's Motion to Exclude
86	2014-07-01	Board	Other	Order - Conduct of the Proceeding - 37 CFR 42.5
87	2014-07-02	Petitioner	Other	Petitioner Microsoft Corporation's Corrected Motion for Observations on Cross-Examination of Reply Witnesses
88	2014-07-07	Potential Patent Owner	Other	Patent Owner Motion re corrected exhibits
89	2014-07-08	Petitioner	Other	Petitioner Transmittal Letter and Updated Exhibit List
1116	2014-07-08	Petitioner		Petitioner's Demonstratives
2093	2014-07-08	Potential Patent Owner		Ex. 2093 - Patent Owner Demonstratives
90	2014-08-08	Board	Other	Record of Oral Hearing
91	2014-08-19	Board	Other	Decision - Additional Motion to Seal 37 C.F.R. 42.14 and 42.54
92	2014-08-27	Board	Other	Order Conduct of the Proceeding
93	2014-10-14	Board	Final Decision	Final Written Decision
94	2014-11-13	Potential Patent Owner	Request for Rehearing	Patent Owner Request for Rehearing
95	2014-11-13	Potential Patent Owner	Other	Patent Owner Transmittal of Updated Exhibit List
96	2015-01-06	Board	Rehearing Decision	Decision - Request for Rehearing - 37 CFR 42.71
97	2015-03-05	Potential Patent Owner	Notice of Appeal	Patent Owner's Notice of Appeal

Grounds Asserted

Not a member? Sign up for free!